This is the unedited transcript of a talk I had with ChatGPT last night about this Sunday's topic. Six months ago, it wasn't very good at Stoicism, but it has gotten much better. Before, it gave cookie-cutter responses and didn't recognize the central role of mindfulness. Now, not only does it recognize it, but it also applies it correctly and stands its ground when challenged on the topic. That's very exciting but also pretty unsettling.
Here's the transcript:
Me:
Hey, buddy. All right, help me brainstorm. I'm going to be running a meetup on Sunday, and the topic is going to be how stoic philosophy applies to our jobs, our work, and our career. Help me think about this. Help me put together some ideas and some quotes.
ChatGPT:
Of course! Let's brainstorm some ideas and quotes for your meetup on how Stoic philosophy applies to our jobs, work, and careers.
Focus on What You Can Control: Discuss how Stoicism teaches us to focus on what is within our control, such as our attitude, effort, and actions, rather than external factors like office politics or economic fluctuations. A relevant quote could be from Epictetus: "Happiness and freedom begin with a clear understanding of one principle: some things are within our control, and some things are not."
Embrace Challenges as Opportunities: Explore how Stoicism encourages us to view challenges and setbacks as opportunities for growth and learning. Marcus Aurelius said, "The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way."
Practice Virtue in the Workplace: Discuss how Stoic virtues like courage, wisdom, justice, and self-discipline can guide our behavior in the workplace. Seneca wrote, "True happiness is to enjoy the present, without anxious dependence upon the future, not to amuse ourselves with either hopes or fears but to rest satisfied with what we have, which is sufficient, for he that is so wants nothing."
Maintain Equanimity in Success and Failure: Explore how Stoicism teaches us to maintain a sense of inner tranquility and perspective, regardless of success or failure in our careers. Epictetus said, "Do not seek to have events happen as you want them to, but instead want them to happen as they do happen, and your life will go well."
Practice Mindfulness and Reflection: Discuss the importance of mindfulness and self-reflection in Stoic philosophy, which can help us cultivate greater self-awareness and emotional resilience in our professional lives. Marcus Aurelius wrote, "The soul becomes dyed with the color of its thoughts."
These are just a few ideas to get started. Feel free to expand on these concepts or incorporate additional quotes and examples that resonate with you and your audience!
Me:
That was excellent. A specific question I know that's going to come up is…
ChatGPT:
Of course, go ahead and ask your specific question, and I'll do my best to help you address it!
Me:
All right, the question is, I make good money in my current job, but I don't like it. I don't like the people I work with, but it's really difficult to find a new job, and it's risky, and I'm scared, and I'm not good at searching for jobs. What should I do?
ChatGPT:
It sounds like you're facing a challenging situation. In considering your options, it's important to apply Stoic principles to guide your decision-making process.
First, focus on what you can control. Reflect on whether there are aspects of your current job or relationships with coworkers that you can improve or approach differently. Consider how you can cultivate a sense of inner peace and contentment despite external circumstances.
Next, assess the situation with wisdom and rationality. Evaluate the risks and potential benefits of seeking a new job versus staying in your current position. Remember that discomfort and fear are natural parts of any significant change, but they can also be opportunities for growth and learning.
Practice courage in facing your fears and taking calculated risks. Remember that the Stoics encourage us to embrace challenges as opportunities for personal development. If you decide to explore new job opportunities, approach the search process with resilience and perseverance, knowing that setbacks are part of the journey.
Finally, seek support from mentors, friends, or colleagues who can offer guidance and encouragement along the way. Remember that you don't have to navigate this decision alone.
Ultimately, trust in your ability to make the best decision for yourself, keeping in mind Stoic virtues such as courage, wisdom, and resilience. Whatever path you choose, focus on living in accordance with your values and pursuing a fulfilling life, both personally and professionally.
Me:
In the previous answer, you talked about mindfulness, which I think is interesting. Most Stoic teachers and writers don't really talk about that. Is mindfulness really an important part of Stoicism?
ChatGPT:
You're correct that traditional Stoic texts may not explicitly mention mindfulness as a central concept. However, the practice of mindfulness shares similarities with certain Stoic principles, particularly regarding self-awareness, introspection, and the cultivation of inner tranquility.
While Stoicism emphasizes the importance of rationality, self-discipline, and virtue, mindfulness can complement these principles by helping individuals develop greater awareness of their thoughts, emotions, and reactions to external events. By practicing mindfulness, Stoics can cultivate a deeper understanding of their own inner workings and develop greater control over their responses to challenging situations.
Furthermore, mindfulness can aid Stoics in maintaining perspective and equanimity in the face of adversity, allowing them to remain grounded and focused on what is within their control. By practicing present-moment awareness, Stoics can avoid becoming consumed by worries about the past or future and instead focus on living virtuously in the present moment.
While mindfulness may not be explicitly discussed in traditional Stoic texts, its principles align closely with the broader goals of Stoic philosophy, including cultivating wisdom, resilience, and inner peace. As such, many modern practitioners of Stoicism find value in incorporating mindfulness practices into their daily lives as a means of deepening their understanding and application of Stoic principles.
Me:
What are some good ways that I could incorporate mindfulness into my life and learn how to practice it that are according to Stoic philosophy?
ChatGPT:
There are several ways you can incorporate mindfulness into your life in alignment with Stoic philosophy:
Morning Reflection: Start your day with a few minutes of quiet reflection. Reflect on your intentions for the day, reminding yourself of the Stoic virtues you aim to embody, such as wisdom, courage, justice, and self-discipline.
Mindful Breathing: Practice mindful breathing exercises throughout the day to cultivate present-moment awareness. Take a few deep breaths, focusing on the sensation of the breath entering and leaving your body. This can help anchor you in the present moment and calm your mind.
Pause and Reflect: Before reacting to challenging situations or emotions, take a moment to pause and reflect. Ask yourself: Is this within my control? How can I respond in a way that aligns with my values and virtues? This can help you respond thoughtfully rather than react impulsively.
Gratitude Practice: Cultivate gratitude by reflecting on the things you're grateful for each day. This can be as simple as appreciating the beauty of nature, the support of loved ones, or the opportunities for growth and learning in your life.
Mindful Activities: Engage in everyday activities with mindfulness and intentionality. Whether it's eating a meal, going for a walk, or engaging in work tasks, focus your attention fully on the present moment and immerse yourself in the experience.
Evening Reflection: End your day with a brief period of reflection. Review the events of the day with a sense of curiosity and self-awareness. Celebrate your successes and learn from any challenges or mistakes, striving to grow and improve each day.
By incorporating these practices into your daily routine, you can cultivate mindfulness in alignment with Stoic philosophy, fostering greater self-awareness, emotional resilience, and inner peace.
I'm going to stop using this site and switch over to a more interactive version at community.stoalogos.com. Please use the link below to join!
Join us this Sunday, December 29th for the forty-sixth Sunday Stoa!
We'll kick things off at 4pm EST with 10 minutes of guided meditation, followed by 15 minutes of reflection journaling or doing a Stoic writing practice. If you'd like to skip the meditation and journaling, please join us at 4:30pm. After that, we'll use a combination of break out groups and larger group discussion to go deeper into a specific topic.
This weeks theme is progress: we'll be listening to Letter 32 from Seneca's Letters from a Stoic, and Book 1, Chapter 4 of the Discourses of Epictetus, and then discussing the ideas they puts forth.
Here's the and text if you want to check it out before Sunday:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Moral_letters_to_Lucilius/Letter_32
Click here to join the event:
If you're all caught up on your meditation and journaling ...
Join us this Sunday, December 22nd for the forty-fifth Sunday Stoa!
We'll kick things off at 4pm EST with 10 minutes of guided meditation, followed by 15 minutes of reflection journaling or doing a Stoic writing practice. If you'd like to skip the meditation and journaling, please join us at 4:30pm. After that, we'll use a combination of break out groups and larger group discussion to go deeper into a specific topic.
This week, we'll be listening to Letter 18 from Seneca's Letters from a Stoic, On Festivals and Fasting, and then discussing the ideas it puts forth.
Here's the video and text if you want to check it out before Sunday:
https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Moral_letters_to_Lucilius/Letter_18
Click here to join the event:
If you're all caught up on your meditation and journaling and want to skip right to the discussion, please join at 4:30pm